Farmers Insurance has been around since 1928, and it’s one of the big names in the U.S. insurance market. A lot of people know it for auto and home coverage, but the company also offers renters, life, and even business insurance. Over the years, I’ve noticed Farmers gets mixed reactions, some folks swear by their customer service, while others feel they pay too much for what they get.
Insurance is tricky because what works for one person might not for another. I had a neighbor in Dallas who stayed with Farmers for 12 years because he liked having a local agent he could call directly. On the flip side, my cousin dropped them after 2 years because the premium hikes were “too much for his budget.”
Have you ever dealt with premium hikes that felt unfair, or do you prefer paying extra for a reliable agent?
Join the discussion below and share your own take.
Coverage Options
Farmers has a wide range of products, which is one of its strongest points:
- Auto Insurance – standard liability, collision, comprehensive, plus optional extras like accident forgiveness.
- Home Insurance – covers the basics and also offers identity theft coverage.
- Renters Insurance – affordable add-on for young adults or people who don’t own a house yet.
- Life Insurance – term and whole life plans.
- Business Insurance – flexible options for small to mid-sized businesses.
Do you prefer a company that offers every type of insurance under one roof, or do you shop around with different providers?
Pricing & Discounts
Farmers isn’t the cheapest, and they admit that. Rates depend heavily on location, age, and driving record. Compared to GEICO or Progressive, it’s usually a bit higher.
That said, they do have solid discounts for:
- Multi-policy (bundling home + auto)
- Good student discounts
- Defensive driving course discounts
- Safe driver rewards
Would you pay more for a dedicated local agent, or do you prefer saving as much as possible online?
Customer Experience
Farmers is known for having agents across the country. If you’re the kind of person who likes walking into an office or calling someone local, that’s a huge plus. On the flip side, some customers say it feels “old school” compared to managing everything online like you can with GEICO.
One reviewer I read on Trustpilot said: “My Farmers agent has been with me for over a decade, and he calls me every year to review my policy. That’s priceless.” Another person said: “Claims take too long, and the prices just keep rising. Not worth it.”
Honestly, I’ve noticed the experience can depend more on your agent than the company itself. A good agent makes all the difference.
Have you ever had an agent go the extra mile for you, or do you think that model is outdated in 2025?
Pros and Cons
- Wide variety of coverage (home, auto, renters, business, life)
- Strong local agent network
- Extra perks like accident forgiveness
- Long history and financial stability
- Premiums usually higher than budget competitors
- Mixed reviews on claims handling speed
- Digital experience feels behind compared to online-first insurers
Conclusion
Farmers Insurance is best suited for people who value personal service and don’t mind paying a little extra for it. If you want the cheapest insurance, you’ll probably be happier with GEICO or Progressive. But if you want a local person to guide you through every step.and you don’t mind the higher bill, Farmers can still be a strong choice in 2025.
I’ll be honest, Farmers is a “love it or leave it” kind of company. Some people won’t trade their agent for anything, while others feel stuck paying more.
So where do you fall? Are you someone who values personal service, or would you rather cut costs and handle everything online?
Join the conversation and let us know.
Read all customer real stories here.
Rating: ★★★★☆ 4/5